3 Retirement Income Mistakes to Avoid

April 11, 2025 Rob Williams
Avoiding simple mistakes can extend the life of your portfolio. Here are three common mistakes retirees make with their retirement income.

After years of diligent saving, many retirees may be unsettled by the notion of actually tapping their portfolios. When should you start withdrawing funds? How much is too much? What if you outlive your money? These are legitimate concerns, but by focusing solely on drawdowns, you could be overlooking other risks to the longevity of your savings.

Let's look at three common mistakes that can negatively impact your retirement income—and what to do about each.

1. Selling assets in a downturn

If your first few years of retirement coincide with a market decline, it may seem that you'd need to sell more of your assets to meet your retirement income goal—leaving you with fewer shares and limiting your portfolio's ability to recover during a potential market rally. If the decline is particularly steep or lasts for an extended period, it's even harder to bounce back.

If a similar decline occurs later in your retirement, you may not need your portfolio to last as long or continue growing to fund a long retirement, so you may be in much better shape to fund withdrawals. 

Timing is everything

This chart looks at how two retirees with identical portfolios and annual withdrawals could see very different results depending on when a market downturn occurred.

Investor 1 experiences a 15% decline in the first two years of retirement. Their portfolio is depleted after 17 years. Investor 2 faces a 15% decline in the ninth and 10th years of retirement and after 20 years has nearly $100,000.

Source: Schwab Center for Financial Research

The example is hypothetical and provided for illustrative purposes only. It is not intended to represent a specific investment product. Dividends and interest are assumed to have been reinvested, and the example does not reflect the effects of taxes or fees.

So, what's an investor to do? 

  • Adjust your allocation: Consider moving a portion of your assets into investments that are more likely to weather market disruptions. We suggest that retirees keep a portion of their retirement portfolio in cash or cash alternatives to help fund expenses. Then, consider allocating some to less-volatile investments, such as high-quality, short-term bonds or short-term bond funds. This can help reduce the risk in a downturn and can be especially important early in retirement.
  • Stay flexible: Regardless of when a downturn occurs, it's important to remain flexible with your spending plan. If you're able to reduce your spending and/or delay large purchases, your portfolio will tend to have a better chance of enduring a decline.

2. Collecting Social Security too early

It's the age-old question: When should I start collecting Social Security? Many Americans opt to collect as soon as they become eligible at 62, but taking benefits before you reach full retirement age (from 66 to 67, depending on your birth year) means settling for smaller payments—for life.

If you are in good health, have a spouse, and are able to wait even a few years longer, you stand to receive a much larger monthly check as the table below shows.

Delayed gratification

As an example, an individual who collects $1,706 from Social Security beginning at age 62 would receive 30% less in monthly benefits than if they had waited until full retirement age (FRA)—and roughly 56% less than if they had waited until age 70.

A 62-year-old begins taking Social Security and receives a monthly benefit of $1,706. If they wait until full retirement age (67
Age 62 67 (FRA) 70
Monthly benefit $1,706 $2,437 $3,022

Waiting to collect can also help extend the life of your portfolio. True, you'll have to rely on your savings alone if you retire several years before you start collecting Social Security, but the increased income that comes with deferral—which is guaranteed for as long as you live—can help preserve your portfolio later.

Furthermore, unlike most other retirement income sources, your Social Security benefit is adjusted upward in response to inflation—so larger cost-of-living adjustments mean bigger checks. Of course, delaying benefits is feasible only if you don't require the funds right away, so discuss your income needs and longevity expectations with a financial planner to bridge the gap if your paycheck stops before Social Security starts.

Will Social Security run out?

A big issue for the soon-to-be retired is the solvency of Social Security, but there are currently no projections of Social Security "bankruptcy."

Social Security payments are funded through payroll taxes collected from current workers under the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) in addition to the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) trust fund reserves, including any interest earned on that money. The 2024 Trustees Report estimates Social Security will be fully funded until 2033 and able to pay 100% of benefits to current and future retirees.

Thereafter, absent any changes from Congress, benefits could be cut by 21%. Several solutions to keep Social Security afloat have been proposed, such as raising the retirement age, increasing the payroll tax rate, or means testing to determine eligibility. But agreement on both sides of the aisle could prove difficult to drive any immediate action.

If you're skeptical about the future of Social Security or wary of potential changes, you may be tempted to start collecting early, believing it's better to have a lower benefit now than none at all down the road. Instead, we suggest using your concern as good reason to save more—and sooner—for retirement.

A big issue for the soon-to-be retired is the solvency of Social Security, but there are currently no projections of Social Security "bankruptcy."

Social Security payments are funded through payroll taxes collected from current workers under the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) in addition to the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) trust fund reserves, including any interest earned on that money. The 2024 Trustees Report estimates Social Security will be fully funded until 2033 and able to pay 100% of benefits to current and future retirees.

Thereafter, absent any changes from Congress, benefits could be cut by 21%. Several solutions to keep Social Security afloat have been proposed, such as raising the retirement age, increasing the payroll tax rate, or means testing to determine eligibility. But agreement on both sides of the aisle could prove difficult to drive any immediate action.

If you're skeptical about the future of Social Security or wary of potential changes, you may be tempted to start collecting early, believing it's better to have a lower benefit now than none at all down the road. Instead, we suggest using your concern as good reason to save more—and sooner—for retirement.

Social Security payments are funded through payroll taxes collected from current workers under the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) in addition to the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) trust fund reserves, including any interest earned on that money. The 2024 Trustees Report estimates Social Security will be fully funded until 2033 and able to pay 100% of benefits to current and future retirees.

Thereafter, absent any changes from Congress, benefits could be cut by 21%. Several solutions to keep Social Security afloat have been proposed, such as raising the retirement age, increasing the payroll tax rate, or means testing to determine eligibility. But agreement on both sides of the aisle could prove difficult to drive any immediate action.

If you're skeptical about the future of Social Security or wary of potential changes, you may be tempted to start collecting early, believing it's better to have a lower benefit now than none at all down the road. Instead, we suggest using your concern as good reason to save more—and sooner—for retirement.

" role="dialog" aria-label="

A big issue for the soon-to-be retired is the solvency of Social Security, but there are currently no projections of Social Security "bankruptcy."

Social Security payments are funded through payroll taxes collected from current workers under the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) in addition to the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) trust fund reserves, including any interest earned on that money. The 2024 Trustees Report estimates Social Security will be fully funded until 2033 and able to pay 100% of benefits to current and future retirees.

Thereafter, absent any changes from Congress, benefits could be cut by 21%. Several solutions to keep Social Security afloat have been proposed, such as raising the retirement age, increasing the payroll tax rate, or means testing to determine eligibility. But agreement on both sides of the aisle could prove difficult to drive any immediate action.

If you're skeptical about the future of Social Security or wary of potential changes, you may be tempted to start collecting early, believing it's better to have a lower benefit now than none at all down the road. Instead, we suggest using your concern as good reason to save more—and sooner—for retirement.

" id="body_disclosure--media_disclosure--332686" >

A big issue for the soon-to-be retired is the solvency of Social Security, but there are currently no projections of Social Security "bankruptcy."

Social Security payments are funded through payroll taxes collected from current workers under the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (FICA) in addition to the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) trust fund reserves, including any interest earned on that money. The 2024 Trustees Report estimates Social Security will be fully funded until 2033 and able to pay 100% of benefits to current and future retirees.

Thereafter, absent any changes from Congress, benefits could be cut by 21%. Several solutions to keep Social Security afloat have been proposed, such as raising the retirement age, increasing the payroll tax rate, or means testing to determine eligibility. But agreement on both sides of the aisle could prove difficult to drive any immediate action.

If you're skeptical about the future of Social Security or wary of potential changes, you may be tempted to start collecting early, believing it's better to have a lower benefit now than none at all down the road. Instead, we suggest using your concern as good reason to save more—and sooner—for retirement.

3. Creating an inefficient distribution strategy

When it's time to turn your retirement savings into income, it might not be as simple as selling investments and pocketing the proceeds. Rather, using your assets to support you in retirement should account not only for your income needs but also for timing, taxes, life expectancy and account types—particularly the way withdrawals from different types of accounts or securities are taxed.

Keep a close eye on taxes and timing—especially once you reach age 73. That's when the IRS obliges you to take the required minimum distributions (RMDs) from your 401(k)s and SEP, SIMPLE, and traditional Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs).2

For example, if RMDs push up your taxable income, you could end up paying more on your regular income and Social Security benefits as well as possibly owing taxes on the long-term capital gains and qualified dividends in your nonretirement accounts.

This is where a retirement income plan and tax-efficient distribution strategy can help. For example, some retirees might choose to take withdrawals from tax-deferred accounts like traditional IRAs prior to age 73—when they have more flexibility to decide how and when to take distributions—in order to help manage the size of the balance held in retirement accounts and, in turn, the amount of tax on RMDs in the future.

Keep in mind that withdrawals from tax-deferred accounts prior to age 59½ may be subject to an additional 10% penalty, so it's usually best to try to avoid withdrawals prior to that age.

Other retirees may opt to convert some of their retirement assets into Roth IRAs,3 which are not subject to annual RMD requirements.

You can't control the markets. But retirees do have more control over fees, taxes and the timing of withdrawals. Whatever you decide, make sure to work with a financial planner and tax advisor to think through the details of your distribution plan.

Final thoughts on retirement planning for income

You can't control the markets, but with thoughtful retirement planning, you can better manage your emotional response to market volatility, taxes, and the timing of your withdrawals to help ensure you'll have enough income to meet your financial goals. A financial planner and tax advisor can help you think through the details of your investment—and distribution—strategy.

How much do you need to retire?

Use Schwab's retirement calculator to estimate if your savings plan is on track. By entering your current age, your age on your retirement date, and investment strategy style, you can test different scenarios to help ensure your financial future.